The Mystery of Planet X: Fact or Fiction?

Call me V
7 min readJan 16, 2023

--

Planet X, also known as “Nemesis” or “Tyche,” is a hypothetical planet that is believed to exist in the outer reaches of our solar system. The concept of Planet X has a long history in popular culture, with theories dating back to the late 19th century. Percival Lowell, an American astronomer, proposed the existence of a “Planet X” beyond Neptune to explain the observed gravitational anomalies of Uranus and Neptune. Since then, the search for Planet X has captivated the public imagination, leading to countless science fiction stories and conspiracy theories.

[Photo: PlanetUser, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons]

The question of whether Planet X is a real, undiscovered planet or simply a myth has been the subject of much debate among scientists and the general public. In this article, we will examine the historical belief in Planet X, the scientific evidence for and against its existence, and ultimately attempt to answer the question: is Planet X fact or fiction?

Historical Belief in Planet X

The idea of a “Planet X” beyond Neptune can be traced back to the late 19th century, when Percival Lowell, an American astronomer, proposed the existence of a massive planet to explain the observed gravitational anomalies of Uranus and Neptune. Lowell spent much of his career searching for this mysterious planet, which he believed to be located in the outer reaches of our solar system, but he never found any definitive evidence of its existence.

In the early 20th century, the search for Planet X was taken up by Clyde Tombaugh, an American astronomer at the Lowell Observatory. Using a telescope and a technique called photographic plate astrometry, Tombaugh discovered Pluto in 1930. At the time, Pluto was considered to be the long-sought “Planet X,” but it was later reclassified as a “dwarf planet” due to its small size and irregular orbit.

Despite the lack of direct observational evidence, the idea of a “Planet X” beyond Pluto has continued to capture the public imagination. In the 1960s, the science fiction writer Zecharia Sitchin popularized the idea of a “12th planet” in his book “The 12th Planet,” which proposed the existence of a massive planet called Nibiru that periodically comes into the inner solar system. This idea has been adopted by some conspiracy theorists, who claim that Nibiru will soon collide with Earth, causing a catastrophic event.

In recent years, the search for Planet X has been reignited by the discovery of several large objects in the Kuiper Belt, a region of the solar system beyond Neptune that is populated by small, icy objects. Some scientists have suggested that the gravitational influence of a massive, undiscovered planet could explain the orbits of these objects. However, the vast majority of scientists believe that the observed gravitational anomalies can be explained by other means, such as the presence of small, undiscovered objects in the Kuiper Belt.

Despite the lack of concrete evidence, the idea of a “Planet X” beyond Pluto continues to captivate the public imagination. The search for this mysterious planet has been the subject of countless science fiction stories and conspiracy theories, and it remains one of the great unsolved mysteries of our solar system. However, it’s worth to note that there have been recent discoveries of exoplanets and the detection of other dwarf planets in the outer solar system, but none of them are considered to be a “Planet X” so far.

[Photo: Jcpag2012, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons]

Scientific Evidence for Planet X

Despite the lack of direct observational evidence, there are several pieces of scientific evidence that have been cited in support of the existence of Planet X. One of the main pieces of evidence is the observed gravitational anomalies of Uranus and Neptune. These anomalies can only be explained by the presence of a massive, undiscovered planet in the outer reaches of our solar system. These anomalies refer to the observed deviations of the orbits of Uranus and Neptune from what would be expected based on the known planets in our solar system.

Another piece of evidence is the behavior of distant objects in the Kuiper Belt, a region of the solar system beyond Neptune that is populated by small, icy objects. The orbits of these objects are not well-explained by the known planets, and some scientists have suggested that the gravitational influence of a massive, undiscovered planet could explain their behavior.

Additionally, there have been several recent discoveries of objects in the outer solar system that are thought to be influenced by the gravity of a massive planet. For example, Sedna, a large trans-Neptunian object, has a highly elongated orbit that cannot be explained by the known planets. It has been suggested that the orbit of Sedna is being influenced by the gravity of a massive, undiscovered planet.

There are also other possible indications of a massive planet, such as the observed discrepancy between the predicted and observed number of small objects in the Kuiper Belt, or the observed alignment of the orbits of distant objects, which could be caused by the gravity of a massive planet.

Some scientists have also proposed that the existence of a massive, undiscovered planet could explain the observed clustering of the orbits of distant objects in the solar system. This clustering, known as the “Kuiper cliff,” is difficult to explain with current models of the solar system, and some scientists believe that it could be caused by the gravity of a massive, undiscovered planet.

[Photo: Konstantin Batygin and Mike Brown, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons]

Scientific Evidence Against Planet X

While there is scientific evidence that has been cited in support of the existence of Planet X, there is also a significant amount of evidence that suggests that a massive, undiscovered planet in the outer reaches of our solar system does not exist.

One of the main pieces of evidence against the existence of Planet X is the lack of direct observational evidence. Despite numerous searches for this planet, no definitive evidence of its existence has been found. This includes both the searches for Planet X conducted in the early 20th century, as well as more recent efforts to detect the planet using methods such as direct imaging and gravitational microlensing.

Another piece of evidence against the existence of Planet X is the lack of a consistent explanation for the observed gravitational anomalies of Uranus and Neptune. While some scientists have proposed that these anomalies could be explained by the presence of a massive, undiscovered planet, other scientists have proposed alternative explanations, such as the presence of a large number of small, undiscovered objects in the Kuiper Belt.

Additionally, the observed discrepancies in the orbits of Uranus and Neptune can also be explained by other factors such as the presence of other undiscovered objects in the solar system, or by the re-evaluation of the mass of these planets.

In recent years, there have been several efforts to detect Planet X using various methods such as direct imaging, gravitational microlensing, or studying the orbits of distant objects. Many of these efforts have yielded negative results, and have failed to find any definitive evidence of Planet X’s existence.

Gravitational microlensing — [Photo: Image credit: NASA Ames/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons]

Current Research Efforts and Recent/Future Discoveries

There are currently several ongoing research efforts and planned future discoveries that could potentially provide new insights into the existence of this hypothetical planet.

One of the main research efforts currently underway is the use of direct imaging to search for Planet X. This method involves using powerful telescopes to take high-resolution images of the outer reaches of our solar system in the hopes of finding a massive, undiscovered planet. Several surveys have been undertaken to search for Planet X, such as the Outer Solar System Origins Survey (OSSOS), the Dark Energy Survey (DES), and the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST), which are expected to produce large amount of data that could be analyzed for the presence of a massive, undiscovered planet.

Another research effort currently underway is the use of gravitational microlensing to search for Planet X. This method involves studying the light from distant stars as it passes through the gravitational field of a massive, undiscovered planet. This can reveal the presence of a massive, undiscovered planet even if it is not directly observable.

Additionally, future discoveries in the outer solar system such as the New Horizons 2 mission, the European Space Agency’s Hera mission, and the upcoming NASA’s Lucy mission, are expected to study the Kuiper Belt and its objects in more detail, which could potentially provide new insights into the existence of Planet X.

It’s worth noting that while the current research efforts and future discoveries are expected to generate a large amount of data that could be analyzed for the presence of a massive, undiscovered planet, it’s unlikely that they will provide a definitive answer to the question of whether Planet X exists or not. The search for this hypothetical planet will likely continue for many years to come.

I kindly invite you to follow me — If you don’t feel such a need, then leave something behind you — a comment or some claps, perhaps. Thank you!

--

--

Call me V
Call me V

Written by Call me V

Knowledge, like air, is vital to life. Like air, no one should be denied it.